Foreman resigns from Black Mountain College in protest
Black Mountain College operated on policies of democracy and unanimity, but its faculty splintered over issues of fairness and accountability. Foreman left to support his colleague and to protest the policy against black students.
Citing this Excerpt
Oral History Interview with Clark Foreman, November 16, 1974. Interview B-0003. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) in the Southern Oral History Program Collection, Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Full Text of the Excerpt
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
Well, there were some members of the faculty who were refuges from
Germany. Al Biers was the chief one and a fellow named Erwin Straus.
They looked upon us as radicals. As we were saying last night, militants
and radicals. Hard to say what's what. We probably did have different
ideas about what was going on. But the main thing at Black Mountain was
that Ted Dreier, who started it, had established it so that he and Al
Biers had permanent tenure. They could never be fired. Everybody else
came on contract. But they also insisted on unanimity. This was
supposedly a Friends [Quaker] concept of consensus. Ted Dreier lay very
heavy emphasis on that. Well, it turned out to be a fraud because he and
Albers could then block anything they didn't want. Because they had
veto, so to speak, if you had to have unanimity. They could block it.
And they could never be fired. Then came this girl, Frances de Graaff,
who had had her contract just renewed. And because she approved of two
of the girls going over to Fisk University for some conference and they
were arrested on their way back for hitchhiking-which they
weren't supposed to do-the older members of the faculty felt
that somehow or other Frances had embarrassed the college and so they
voted to fire her. Even though she had a valid contract for two more
years. Eric Bentley andFritz Cohen and I and
several others felt this was a pretty outrageous thing to do. And if
they could do it to Frances of course they could do it to us and would
have done it to us the next year. So we resigned.
BILL FINGER
Have you read Martin Duberman's account of that? What did you think of
it?
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
I thought it was pretty good.
- JACQUELYN HALL:
-
What was it about Black Mountain that attracted you in the first place?
Were you interested in educational innovation or in the communitarian
aspects of the place?
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
Yeah, I was interested in education and in the freedom in which they
worked and the fact that the students were allowed to have such
initiative. The students were the ones who took the initiative in
getting me there in the first place and getting me going. And I thought
that was fine.
- JACQUELYN HALL:
-
What was it like to live there?
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
Well, it was like a summer camp but very informal and a little bit
detached from life . . . from the rest of life. A little bit too idyllic
in a sense for living.
- JACQUELYN HALL:
-
How did you like the communal aspect of it? The intense personal
relationships.
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
Well, I didn't like eating together in the dining hall. I thought that
the privacy of our own home was much more desirable. I don't know of any
other communal aspects . . . . We had our own house and we had our own
meals there, later. But the communal aspects, I don't know what you
mean.
BILL FINGER
Did the men help take care of the children and cook and things like that?
As well as the women.
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
Did I help . . .
[Laughter.]
Sure, always. Before and after Black Mountain but my wife says
I'm not geared to housework.
BILL FINGER
But the Black Mountain environment didn't encourage sharing of the child
rearing responsibilities.
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
No. I don't think so.
- JACQUELYN HALL:
-
When you went there in the first place did you think you could
push the school toward becoming an integrated
school?
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
No, I didn't have any such idea. Once I was there . . . it came up sort
of gradually as to why we didn't have Negro students. I was in favor of
it and I think that Frances deGraff and Eric Bentley were in favor of it
too, the same. But the older ones were frightened. They were frightened
that we were going to be persecuted, you see. And they had been through
very hard times in Germany and they had reason to be frightened, I
suppose. We were going to antagonize the community by doing something .
. . .
- JACQUELYN HALL:
-
So you all resigned over Frances de Graaff's firing?
- CLARK FOREMAN:
-
Yeah.