Threats from the Ku Klux Klan and their immediate impact
Carter describes the types of threats he received from the Ku Klux Klan after he began to openly criticize their organization and its tactics during the early 1950s. The threats ranged from economic threats against his newspaper to threats of physical violence against him, his family, and his home. Carter also describes the impact of such threats on his family and on the newspaper, arguing that while circulation went down, his opposition to the Klan generated nearly as many new readers as it lost.
Citing this Excerpt
Oral History Interview with W. Horace Carter, January 17, 1976. Interview B-0035. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) in the Southern Oral History Program Collection, Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Full Text of the Excerpt
- JERRY LANIER:
-
At the time were you threatened directly by the klansmen?
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
Just about every way that you can be threatened—and again, I
don't want to be threatened as any great hero in the deal.
But it was almost a daily occurrence that we had the threats: in the
mail, put under the door of the print shop, under the windshield wiper
of my car, as well as the telephone messages to my home. These were
daily for several years.
- JERRY LANIER:
-
Well, what type of threats were they? Please don't be modest;
it's interesting to see the Klan making direct threats to
someone like this.
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
Well, the threats were first, "You better get off our backs. You
don't know what you're talking about. The
Klan's down here to do a good job in Columbus and Overy
counties, and if you don't get off our backs your house is
going to burn, or you're going to find that you
don't have any print shop one of these mornings."
And then the more subtle kind of threats were those having to do with
economics. They'd say, "You've got X
number of advertisers in Tabor City now, but you're not going
to have any if you keep this thing up against the Klan." And I
know that they brought great pressure upon what few advertisers we had.
Our situations then, as I often told me wife, was, "We came
down here with nothing, and we don't have anything now. And
so we can't be any worse off then we were
[Laughter] when we came." That was
the biggest, the only threat I worried as much about…. I
worried more about that threat than I did the physical threats, because
I felt like that if they had enough following they can go to one of the
grocery stores that was helping keeping us in business, and they could
put enough of his customers to go to that fellow and say, "You
know, if this guy Carter doesn't quit running this Klan thing
now, we're going to quit buying
groceries from you." And they can squeeze you out of business
pretty quick in a little town where you don't have but forty
or fifty businesses to start with.
- JERRY LANIER:
-
Were the children and the rest of your family threatened by the
klansmen?
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
Well, at that moment I only had my one daughter who was very small, and
so she was too young to realize any of the consequences. My wife was,
with reason, nervous and upset over the entire time. I think she would
have been very happy to have left Tabor City and never come back. The
threats were general threats as to burning my home and print shop, or I
was going to get it myself one of these nights (one of these floggings)
if I didn't watch what we were saying. And the Grand Dragon
himself came to see me; I think you might have read something about
that.
- JERRY LANIER:
-
Well, Mr. Carter, did these threats have an impact? Did your advertising
go down?
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
We lost some advertising; we didn't have much, but we lost
some of what we did have. But I'd have to say that generally
my advertisers stuck with us reasonably well. Even some of my best
advertisers, though, came to me and indicated that they'd
like for me take it easy on the Klan, because they were being pressured
not to advertise with us. I still appreciate the fact that enough of
them hung with us that we managed to survive.
- JERRY LANIER:
-
Well, was your circulation affected? I don't guess
that's quite so important, but it would seem to be an
indicator of Klan strength, perhaps, anyway.
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
We were so young at the time that our circualtion was minor
anyway—our newspaper itself was so young at the time. But we
lost some, and the ones that we lost, you know
they made a big deal out of it. They'd write you or come by
and call you or something, and say, "I want my name taken off,
because you're criticizing the Ku Klux Klan." But in
all honesty I would say we probably picked up as many as we lost from
people who … wouldn't come out and talk for the
Klan or against the Klan, but at least they wanted to see what they were
doing—curiosity if nothing else. So I don't feel
that we actually lost circulation because of it, although obviously we
had some who cancelled subscriptions and didn't want the
paper anymore. But we also had some who read it because of what we were
saying.