Reflection on the male facutly who resisted feminism in the academy
When asked about opposition to feminist faculty initiatives, O'Connor responds with a great deal of empathy, reflecting on how the male faculty must have felt besieged, attacked, and put upon. She also remembers how, as a female faculty member, she gained a certain degree of freedom that other junior faculty did not enjoy.
Citing this Excerpt
Oral History Interview with Margaret Anne O'Connor, July 1, 1987. Interview L-0031. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) in the Southern Oral History Program Collection, Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Full Text of the Excerpt
Were there sources of opposition to the idea in general that
surfaced at all in those early discussions?
MARGARET ANNE O'CONNOR:
Yes. Very, very clearly, but today, after sixteen years of being here, I
really feel that the major opposition was one of inertia.
I've described this as a conservative institution. I think
that some of my colleagues might take umbrage at that. After all, this
is a campus that in the 30's was a leader for the South in
liberal attitudes and ideas, but really I don't think those
values had changed very much since the 1930's. And this
campus was open to black students before it was open to women students.
In some ways, there was some question about women
that really struck at the heart of the institution. You would have to
check, but my impression of my first few years here was that a large
number of the University administrators, in particular, and the
administrators of specific departments were UNC-Chapel Hill graduates.
They had a sense of this institution as male. It was a part of their
memory as well as their present and their futures. I really felt that
they believed that a change in standards, a change in values, would be a
lowering and that, inevitably, there was a fear of anything that might
disrupt the status quo. It was a time, too, that major universities,
including UNC, had just recently gotten through major upheavals and
changes in civil rights and the anti-war movement of the late
'60's. And they were just beginning to lick their
wounds. The last thing that they really wanted to do was to be told that
their whole way of looking at one another, as well as the world, was
warped. I think that issue so often touched the idea of fairness. You
can make some suggestions in the abstract, but this was very concrete.
Here were men who, in many cases, were very happily married, the
husbands and the fathers and the sons of women. And they felt an
implicit criticism of not only their academic and their public role but
of their whole personal way of responding to women, which, of course,
now sixteen years later, we can see is absolutely true. It really was,
and it has…
- PAMELA DEAN:
-
They knew a threat when they saw one.
MARGARET ANNE O'CONNOR:
They knew a threat when they saw it. I felt, for myself, a kind of
freedom that a lot of my male colleagues did not feel in their first
five years here, and a kind of a resentment.
I've had a chance to talk to them about that since then. When
I was first brought into the faculty, it was when the English faculty
definitely were trying to cover their asses, really, because they had
let the single tenure-track woman go the year before, and they really
had to try and look better. There were some people who were trying to
make some sincere changes. They were expecting to get criticism from
people like me and from Connie Eble, who was the assistant professor
hired the year I was hired as an instructor. We really had the kind of
freedom to stand up in front of our colleagues to chastise them and
shake our fingers at them and say, "Why aren't you
doing this?" in a way that any assistant professor or
instructor might want to change the world. And a lot of my male
colleagues did not have the freedom I had. I mean, they
couldn't walk out and be angry at me for saying what they
expected me to say. So there was a kind of freedom at the same time that
the some of early women…
- PAMELA DEAN:
-
That's very interesting and not what I'd expect at
all.
MARGARET ANNE O'CONNOR:
When I was considered for tenure, I had a very strong vote. And I think a
lot of that came from a sense that even colleagues that were reticent
about accepting the sorts of changes that I was very anxious to see put
in, couldn't begrudge my attempt. I could be very specific
and talk about our Chancellor, who was very anxious to avoid the kind of
upheavals of the late '60's.
- PAMELA DEAN:
-
Who was Chancellor?
MARGARET ANNE O'CONNOR:
N. Farabee Taylor. As gentlemanly as he was, my visual memories of
Chancellor Taylor are going to be seeing him chain smoking in front of
the Faculty Council. I bet he must have smoked three or four packs of
cigarettes a day. He fell very much under fire, and when I heard of his
subsequent heart attack, and happily his recovery, and now
he's in the law school, it occurred to me that a lot of the
pressures that were being put on him as an administrator of those years
were very visible at just those sorts of meetings between the faculty
and the Chancellor. But at the same time that I can now empathize with
him, at the time I just thought, "I don't know who
he's looking after, but he's not looking after the
women at this campus." I felt very, very embattled, and
I'm sure that, from his point of view, that was a very warped
perspective, mine. On a different level, I felt that Jim Gaskin, who
went from the chair of the English Department to Dean of the College of
Arts and Sciences the year after I came, was very anxious to get as many
qualified women on the faculty as he possibly could and encouraged all
sorts of departments. And that's where I saw amazing gains. I
felt that he approached it with good will, with compassion, and tried to
make the very best of a difficult situation.
- PAMELA DEAN:
-
So you wouldn't make any blanket statements that men were the
enemy in this situation?
MARGARET ANNE O'CONNOR:
Men were in charge, and the people in charge were the enemy. What can I
say? There were no women. I'll be happy to share the blame,
but you'd have to go back and revise your statement. And I
think it's absolutely true that many of the men
woke up and looked around themselves and saw a lot of
people just like them who agreed with them one hundred percent. There
really weren't many ways that new faces, male or female,
could break into that system. I still feel that very few women,
VERY few women, have broken into that ring.