Assessing lingering economic crises in Mecklenburg County
Fillette offers his assessment on the gap between the poor and the wealthy in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. After arguing that some of the most deplorable situations of low-income people had been ameliorated since the early 1970s, he argues that a marked disparity still existed, emphasizing perpetually low wages as evidence. Fillette also discusses the role of race in continuing economic crises and argues that disparity within the public school system was symptomatic of larger divisions within the community.
Citing this Excerpt
Oral History Interview with Ted Fillette, April 11, 2006. Interview U-0186. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) in the Southern Oral History Program Collection, Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Full Text of the Excerpt
- SARAH THUESEN:
-
Just by way of summing up then, how would just describe the progress
Charlotte has made in the time you've worked here and lived
here, in terms of closing the gap between rich and poor?
- TED FILLETTE:
-
Well, I think that the severity of the conditions poor people lived in
from the early 1970s and before, I think has certainly been ameliorated.
I think that the quality of the housing now is so much better as a
result of state law changes and also some amendments to the housing
code, including the requirement that there actually be heating equipment
in the houses. I think that the city inspection process has worked well.
I think the landlord community has largely accepted the new
responsibilities. What has not happened is there is any real improvement
in the economic buying power of the lower-income community. The minimum
wage has remained so low and the welfare payment level is so low and the
disability compensations are so low, that the people at the lowest
strata of the community can barely afford to live here. If they can get
more income from any sources, they can do much better. I mean, I think
there is a whole lot available in terms of amenities in housing and good
places to live and work. This is not unique to Charlotte.
It's true all over the state and all over the country. I
think the economic trends show that. There's not much you can
do tinkering with a local government and a local economy that will
address that. That's sort of the new reality.
- SARAH THUESEN:
-
If it can't be done on the local level, what do you think
ultimately is going address this wage and income gap you're
describing?
- TED FILLETTE:
-
I can't quite get a vision of that. I think it's
going to be a crisis that will have to get to a certain proportion where
people that have a political interest in fixing it will speak on behalf
of the lowest-income strata. That is, enough employers will start to
say, "We've got to have more
affordable housing because we can't have workers close enough
to our places to operate what we have, what we need to fill with
workers, and the workers are going to have enough skills to do what we
do. So we're going to have to have enough educational
training and enough competence from the school system to work.
We're going to have to have enough income in the families so
that the kids who come to school aren't coming ill-clothed
and hungry." It's really the entire package of what
it takes for people to survive and be successful at a decent level.
They're all sort of inextricable from one another. People
that make minimum wage now cannot afford decent homes, rental or
ownership, without some other supplement. It just doesn't
work. The North Carolina Justice Center has published some great studies
that demonstrate how minimum wage will not buy half of what it takes to
live and own a car and rent a home and feed and clothe people; it will
not do that. I think as that phenomenon grows, it's going to
create crises in other institutions that I think will force some
change.
- SARAH THUESEN:
-
What role do you see race playing in the crises that you're
describing here?
- TED FILLETTE:
-
Well, I think that in the short run, it's the general
perception that all poor people are people of color and that is somewhat
of a hindrance, I think, to conservative-dominated legislatures at the
state and federal level to want to address them. It's very
unclear what impact this national crisis over immigrants and
particularly Latinos will have on this. My thought is that how that is
resolved will also impact the whole issue of minimum wages, health care
provision, and funding of schools in a way that we've never
seen before. It's extremely important that Mecklenburg County
is now a predominately non-white school system. I'd say that
it's very much up for grabs as to whether or not the
upper-middle-class leadership in this community is going to continue to
support and provide resources for the school system or abandon the
school system, like what has happened in most of the metropolitan
communities in this country. I look at what
happened in Mobile, where the middle-class leadership has abandoned the
public school systems and you've got three school systems.
You've got the private school system, the parochial school
system, and the public school system, which is predominately black and
poorly funded. If Charlotte-Mecklenburg goes to that level where they
can't pass bonds for school expansion and they
can't pay enough salaries to get good enough teachers to
maintain order and decent scores for their students, I think it will
deteriorate into essentially a second-class system that will not be
redeemed.
- SARAH THUESEN:
-
So in other words, we can sort of look to the schools to see where the
rest of the city's health is?
- TED FILLETTE:
-
I think that's it a great barometer. Right now, the Chamber of
Commerce in Charlotte is saying, "We need to go ahead and
support the schools and maintain them, because companies, leaders that
are considering Charlotte, want to know about whether the public school
system is positive or not." As long as they still ask that and
the Chamber of Commerce wants to attract more business to the community,
then they see that as something that has to be addressed. But if it ever
gets to the point where the whispering campaign says, "You can
forget the public schools. Everybody of substance is going to go to
private schools and it doesn't matter," then we will
have completely institutionalized class strata in every way. I think
because of what Judge McMillan did with the school system and the
Supreme Court upholding it, we had a truly integrated school system
where the upper-middle-class and the lower-class people had a common
stake to make a school system work. That was probably the overarching
point of contact for people of different races and classes here for
thirty years. If that source of contact and common interest is lost, I
think we will have an almost irreversible disconnect between the poor
and the wealthy in this community.