How, Thomas Y.
Your letter contains an account of a conversation with Gener[al
Da]vie
on
the evidence of
Christianity. The manner in which [you] reasoned with him was
very judicious and forcible. [I hope] it will prompt him to enquire with
accuracy into the subj[ect.] The progress of
Deism in the Southern States is a
most atorning and melancholy circumstance, and it is the du[ty
of] every friend to virtue to exert himself with incessant torn
in opposing a system that will corrupt our morals and torn our
liberty. The general prevalence of Atheism and
Deis[m] among a people is a sure
mark of a corrupted state of soci[ety.]
Page 2
[Wh]en men
are extremely addicted to soft and luxurious plea[sures] they soon become
Infidels, in order to remove every obstacle [to the g]ratification of their
passions. And as soon as religion is open[ly and] generally ridiculed, Society
will go to decay with incredible tornty. The Romans, in the pure
times of the republic, were re[mark]able for a most sacred attention to their
religion and an in[torn]ble regard for their oaths— But when the
violence of factorn had destroyed their morals, and the Asiatic
wars by ac[quain]ting them with the riches of the
East, had introduced lux[uries] and rendered them extravagantly fond of
effeminating [pleas]ures, the doctrines of an overruling providence, and of a
torn state of rewards and punishments soon gave way torn the [At]heism and the mortality of the Soul. After it became
[the gen]eral belief that there is no invisible Judge of our actions [and no]
existence beyond the grave, the Roman manners hasten[ed to] that state of
profligacy and debauchery which we rea[d of in] the time of
Cicero. And,
how could it be otherwise? Man [is na]turally prone to the gratification of his
passions. Take [from] them the powerful restraints which are imposed by the fear
[of futu]re punishment, and what is there to curb his irregular [appe]tites and
desires! The sanguinary monsters that have de[luged]
France with blood, in order to prepare the
people for the [comm]ission of every crime, and thereby carry their nefarious
[purpos]es into execution, wrote over the burying
grounds "This torn place of eternal
sleep." It had the desired effect. It torn [a]way all
restraint upon the vicious passions of the heart. illegible
Frenchmen to commit the most horrid crimes without
Page 3
remorse or fear. You will perhaps stare when I advance [the] firm opinion that
the government of
France
has sent e[missa]ries to this country for the express purpose of converting th[e
peop]le to
Deism. And, why! Because our people will in torn case
soon lose their republican virtue, and
France
will torn by intrigues and bribery to govern our politics.
I promised occasionally to give you accounts of the proceedings of the Society,
and as something interesting has lately happened, the remainder of this letter
[will] be occupied in relating it to you. Towards the close of las[t ses]sion
two parties began to be formed. At the beginning of th[e ses]sion, several of
the members predicted that we should [be] torn by faction. An event soon
happened which divided [the] Society and fixed the parties in battle array
against [one] another.
John and
William Alston
brothers of
Josep[h Al] ston,
John Forsyth and
Frederick Nash were
propose[d for] admission. The request of
John Alston came on first,
whtorn Class unanimously declared him to be a bad scholar
torn unworthy of a seat. The proposal for his admission
[was] then withdrawn, as was also that for the admission [of his] brother. The
request of
John Forsyth was next consider[ed] when four persons
Bailey,
Peyton,
Jackson and
Alsto[n evi]dently actuated by motives of revenge, spoke
agains[t him.] This brought on a very lengthy and interesting debate. [The]
evidence of the Class and of the oldest members was torn highly
in
Forsyth's favor. We at length prevailed upon
[Jack]son to withdraw his opposition, and upon
Bailey
and
Page 4
Pey[ton to leave] the room. The question was then taken, and no
person torn in opposition but the infamous
Alston
. I never was more torned than on this occasion. I had
formed a very good [opinio]n of
John Forsyth's disposition and
capacity, and the torn that he should be kept out by two such
contemptible torn as
Alston and
Jackson filled me with indignation. [I can] not describe to you my
feelings when after a long an torn ated discussion, the cause of
truth and justice pre[vai]led. But what followed was very mortifying. As soon
torn proposal for
Nash's admission was read,
Alston an[d
Jack]son declared they would oppose him, and nothing that torn said had any influence upon them. The pro[posa]l was
withdrawn. The next evening it was again [broug]ht forward, when the rascals did
not say decidedly [whet]her they would continue their opposition or not.
[Fri]ends of order resolved, during the week, if the opposi[tion] should be
continued, to endeavor to suspend
Alston from [the] Society. The
opposition was continued notwithstanding [the u]nanimous testimony of the Class,
and notwithstanding [a] letter from
Hobart
declaring M
r Nash to be a
good [scho]lar and a worthy student. Upon this
John Watson
torn walked solemnly to the Table, and wrote a proposal [for]
the suspension of
Alston. This brought on a very torn debate which ended in the appointment of a [com]mittee to consider the
proposal, and to report whe[ther] or not it ought to be adopted. The Committee
reported [that] the proposal was unconstitutional,
Mr. Alston being
[a me]mber of the Counsel, and the Constitution declaring tha[t "no of
]ficer shall be impeached or censured, while in the execution of the duties of
his office under penalty of very severe punishment." The
Constitutionality of the proposal was of course the first subject of enquiry. We
contended both from the Spirit and letter of the law, that an Officer is
protected from censure and punishment, while in the
Page 5
execution of the duties of his office, only for his conduct as an Officer.
That the object of the Constitution, in specifically
providing for the censure and impeachment of Officers, is to punish them for the
neglect or transgression of those duties which
as
Officers they are required to perform. We observed that the construction
for which the Committee contended is opposed by the immemorial and daily
practice of the Society, the Censor, Correctors and all the officers torn censured and punished as well as the other members, [for]
the neglect of their exercises, or for any indecencies during the time of order.
The vote was at last taken when 15 declared the proposal to be illegal, and 26
declared it to be strictly constitutional. Then came on the main question. The
evidence being taken, both sides prepared for the combat. A number of long
speeches were made.
Hobart
delivered the most eloquent speech that
I ever heard in the Whig Hall.
Mercer and
Watson also
spoke well. On the other side
Bailey
fatigued us with a long speech, and
Otto
the slave of popularity spoke several times. At length, between the hours
of 2 and 3 in the morning the question was taken, when 20 voted against and 21
in favor of the suspension. So we carried our point by a majority of one vote.
Six graduates were present—
Hobart,
Forsyth,
Comfort,
John Smith,
Stille and
myself—We all voted for the proposal. Some of the members are much
exasperated at us and threaten to deprive us of the privilege of
voting—But this they dare not attempt.