Henderson, Pleasant, 1756-1840
Page 1
Chapel
Hill
Dear Sir,
I hasten to communicate to you a sketch of the strange procedure of a
majority of the Students on the establishment, say forty-five; knowing full
well it will affect your mind and call forth all your
"energies" unitedly with the rest of the Board
to counteract its remote consequences — the immediate are past
control.
Ever since the
board, here in July, past the ordinance
directing that the Monitors should perform their official duties under the
obligation of an oath a grumbling and discontent hath obtained among them.
Caucuses have been held; various plans I suppose have been proposed and at
length one digested, i.e. That they should remonstrate through the medium of
the Faculty to the
Trustees against the ordinance which so set
their teeth on edge. This they accordingly did at great length; and
Mr. Caldwell
instantly forwarded on the original paper to
the president of the
Board at
Raleigh. The
Trustees there taking the matter
under consideration
Page 2
ordained that that part of
the ordinance should stand suspended which imposed on the Monitors an oath
until the annual meeting; and that in lieu thereof the Monitors should
pledge their words of honor to perform their duties. This I understood was
all the modification they required or at least was modifying the ordinance
in a manner suited to their objections and tastes. The
Trustees lost no time
in sending up the amendatory ordinance because new Monitors were to be
appointed the first of the present month.
They act for a month. Directly on the receipt of the ordinance they take it
into their heads that no modification of the Law had taken place. That there
was not in fact any difference between a man swearing to do a thing and his
promising to do it, and therefore they, the signers, would withdraw
themselves from College unless the Faculty &
Trustees would
concede to alter the monitorial duties in a manner as suited them; a plan of
which they submitted to
Mr. Caldwell
. This dictatorial
conduct was so novel and so inadvisable that
Mr. Caldwell
could not listen to it a single minute; indeed his oath to carry into
execution the Laws of the institution absolutely forbade
Page 3
him from doing any such a thing, and strange as
it is to reason and common sense forty-five have actually seceded and almost
all the larger Boys among them. They are going off different ways home as
fast as they can procure horses.
Mr. Caldwell
Sunday evening sent on their ultimatum to
Raleigh by
post, and I expect the
Trustees here by 12 o'clock this day. I don't
know that
Mr. Caldwell
asked them to come, but I suppose
he did as it is a matter of great moment, and I am sure they are sensible
how important it is to be here to affix a punishment adequate to the
delinquency and to fix on some plan of counteracting the rebellion by making
a full statement to the public or otherwise as their wisdom may suggest. The
crisis is awful, and I hope you will come up this evening or early in the
morning in the hope of meeting a Board and joining your exertions to
counteract this strangest of all strange procedures. A thousand
circumstances not worth noting in a letter the case involves & which
you will hear when you come up.
Respectfully, sir, your most obedient,
Henderson
Sept. 3rd 1805
Walter Alves Esqr