Opposition to the vigilante tactics of the Klan
Carter again explains how his opposition (as well as that of others) was largely a reaction to the vigilante tactics the Ku Klux Klan employed during the early 1950s. Carter explains how many residents of Columbia County, North Carolina and surrounding areas sometimes agreed with the Klan's views on certain behaviors they deemed "immoral." Nevertheless, most found the tactic of flogging and other physical violence abhorrent. In this regard, Carter lauds the courage of those who stepped forward to accuse their attackers and to help the federal case against the Klan. Overall, his comments here reveal the complex relationship of various factors in determining how people in that community understood the Klan and its actions.
Citing this Excerpt
Oral History Interview with W. Horace Carter, January 17, 1976. Interview B-0035. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007) in the Southern Oral History Program Collection, Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Full Text of the Excerpt
- JERRY LANIER:
-
Well, Mr. Carter, now do you know the klansmen in the county now? Do you
think there's an active Klan in this county?
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
I don't think there's any klansmen in the county
that have any …. Let me put it this way: I don't
think there's any card-carrying klansmen to speak
of—there might be a handful. But I don't think
there are any card-carrying klansmen to think of. But I think we still
have some people who think like the Klan thought; I think we still have
some that would sympathize with the very things that the Klan was
promoting at that time. Now, this may not be the time to say it, but
somewhere we need to point out this basic fact about the Klan: we have
never (then or now) tried to say anything good about the character of
the people that they flogged. And I think that's one reason
the Klan had some following then and some sympathizers then, because
these beatings that they administered and their form of justice on these
people, generally speaking the people that they punished had a lot
lacking in their character and they deserved some kind of punishment.
But our crusade was that this group of vigilantes were not the one to do
the punishing. Of course, their rebuttal to this was, "Nobody
else is doing anything about it." So they had some argument;
and this made some people pro-Klan, because they'd say,
"Well, I hear of these few people that are leading these
immoral lives, and they've been doing it for ten years and
the children out there are suffering, and nothing's being
done about it." So the Klan did something about it: they put
the whip to them. We posed it anyway as we would now. But I did want to
point out the fact that some people were
sympathetic to the Klan because they could foresee some deserved
punishment by these people.
- JERRY LANIER:
-
Well, did you personally know or were you acquainted with any of the Klan
victims?
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
Only to a nodding acquaintance kind of way. I mean, some of these people
in this area who were beaten up (some blacks and some whites), I would
know the name if I saw them on the street but I had no real close
association.
- JERRY LANIER:
-
In your estimation, Mr. Carter, were there a lot of floggings that were
never reported or never came to light?
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
I think there were a lot more that weren't reported than were
reported. And I thank God for the ones that were reported, because if
they hadn't been reported the FBI and the SBI would have had
nothing to go on, and we would have been in a bad position. But the fact
that some of these people had the courage to report them, I think that
is a major point in the whole episode, because had they not gone to the
sheriff or somebody and told their stories they would have broken the
case.
- JERRY LANIER:
-
Well, perhaps some of that can be attributed to newspaper report they
received.
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
I believe that if the newspapers hadn't said anything,
hadn't even offered any crusade against this activity at all,
I doubt seriously that it would ever have been broken. In the first
place, I doubt if anybody would have talked; second, I doubt that the
FBI would have ever gotten involved with it. I think it's one
of the purposes that perhaps we served, to get enough attention focused
on it that it did get the FBI interested. And if we hadn't, I
don't believe the local law enforcement would have ever
broken it. I think here might also be a time to
say a good word for the Raleigh News and Observer,
because I think as long as Willard and I were talking about it down here
in the county and nobody else was saying much about it, that perhaps we
would have had a hard time….
[END OF TAPE 1, SIDE A]
[TAPE 1, SIDE B]
[START OF TAPE 1, SIDE B]
- W. HORACE CARTER:
-
… in this campaign against the Ku Klux Klan, because they were
a big newspaper with a big circulation. And they sent Jay Jenkins down
here, who was working with the state editor at that time, and Jay did a
lot of talking to Willard Cole and myself and came to some of the public
meetings. And they publicized the Klan activities and the floggings with
some big banner headlines on the front page, and I think this helped to
get the FBI interested in it. They saw it as more than just any little
small town/rural county problem, but that it could grow into a state and
national problem.